Difficult Conversations at Work: How L&D Can Support New Managers

Managers guide, lead and motivate their teams. But despite the crucial nature of their roles, Personnel Today says that 77% of managers never received specialized training when they were hired or promoted. And a further 75% never – or rarely – were given additional training after their onboarding.

‍

The outcome is a cohort of managers who feel unprepared for important responsibilities, like conducting difficult conversations. A normal and unavoidable part of work for most leaders, these interactions occur in every team and with nearly every customer. They also have many causes, ranging from personality conflicts to gaps in performance, motivation or skills. Though they can be intense, the right tools and approaches will help your managers adopt the mindset and behavior needed to reach a successful outcome. Here are 4 strategies L&D leaders can share:

‍

1. Encourage your manager to talk to themselves

Having an internal discussion about a conversation before it takes place provides a chance for your manager to ask questions they might otherwise overlook. For example:

‍

• Why is the idea of this conversation making me uncomfortable?
• What exactly is making me feel worried?
• Am I afraid of ruining a relationship that I’ve worked hard to build?
• Am I concerned about stirring up conflict instead of resolving it?
• Am I afraid that I lack the skills needed to communicate effectively?

‍

When they’ve considered these questions, and developed strong answers, they’ll lessen their anxiety and the chance of feeling unprepared when the pressure is on. 

‍

2. Encourage your manager to talk to someone else

Remind your manager that a difficult conversation (which will take place with a certain person and focus on a specific situation) should resemble a conversation they’d have with someone else about that person and situation.

‍

For example, have them imagine that they’re going to discuss things with your HR lead. They wouldn’t blame them for what happened. Instead, they’d likely outline the situation, stick to the facts and discuss possible solutions. This is exactly what a real-life difficult conversation should look like. Facts and logic need to take precedence over emotion and blame. Collaborating with HR can help your new manager separate the emotional side of a situation from the logical one, making these interactions incredibly valuable.

You might also like: 6 Proven Strategies to Build a Strong Team Culture
‍

3. Suggest a word association game

Encourage your manager to think about what they want to say during the conversation and write down words that come to mind. Once they’ve made a list, have them add associated words and phrases and then review them. How do these notes make them feel?

‍

Maybe they planned to say that “Akeem feels isolated.” But the word “isolated” can have negative connotations and might lead to an unpleasant reaction. Instead, it could be better to say “Akeem feels like he’s unable to participate or contribute.” This gets the message across without assigning blame. Being particular about words might seem trivial, but it can make a big difference.

‍

4. Engage in a roleplay session

The idea of roleplay can fill some people with dread. But there’s no need for your manager to act out an entire conversation. Instead, have them focus on working through various scenarios, anticipating what could happen and determining what questions the other person may ask.

‍

This approach shares similarities with our 1st suggestion: Have your manager talk to themselves. Remind them that coming up with the questions they’re likely to face requires fully engaging with the situation. It’s not enough to simply try thinking about it from someone else’s perspective. They should take notes, work through several scenarios and think deeply.

You might also like: Types of Leadership Styles: Which is Best for You and Your Organization?
‍

Helpful scenarios to get your manager started

Practice makes perfect, so encourage your manager to try out some of these roleplay scenarios to prepare them for real life conversations.

‍

• Scenario #1: An employee is speaking to – and about – another employee in a disrespectful way.

‍

What your manager might normally say: “I don’t appreciate your tone or the way you’re speaking to Ishani. Please stop. That’s not the way you talk to someone. I won’t allow it in the future. You should apologize to her.”

‍

Their likely goal in this context is to realign their employee’s behavior. But this kind of interaction is likely to make the other person feel defensive, unappreciated and misunderstood. That’s why the most important question they can ask themselves before trying to change someone’s behavior is “What’s my mindset?”

‍

The more aware we are of our own mindset (and how it makes us behave) the clearer our goals become. And the closer we’ll be to achieving them. Here’s a better response your manager could provide in this scenario:

‍

“Do you have a moment to talk about what happened with Ishani? I appreciate how hard you’ve been working on meeting your sales quota this quarter. And I know you snapped at her because you want the rest of the team to reach their targets. In the future, maybe you can show her more empathy. She’s also under lots of pressure. How do you feel about apologizing?”

‍

A statement like this will make the other employee feel more valued. By identifying with their situation, and showing them how to be softer with Ishani, your manager can hopefully avoid inflaming the situation. A culture built on empathy and understanding is always better than one based on harsh reprimands.

‍

• Scenario #2: An employee is continuing to work fully remote from another country when company policy allows for only 50% remote work.

‍

What your manager might normally say: “Our company policy says you can only work remotely 50% of the time. You’ve been in another country for weeks now, so please come back. And the next time you want to work from abroad, let your manager know.”

‍

At first glance, this conversation seems like it would get results. The employee would probably feel like they don’t have a choice and stop working from abroad. But your manager will also create resentment and erode trust. The employee might ask why they can’t keep working in another country and feel like the manager doesn’t believe they’ll actually get things done. Your manager should try saying something like this instead:

‍

“I know our remote work policy wasn’t clear in the past. But we’ve updated it and believe it’s important that we spend time together as a team. If you have any issues or concerns, please don’t hesitate to speak up. Otherwise, can you let us know what your plans for working remotely look like in advance? Hopefully, we can find a way to make things work for everyone.”

‍

In this scenario, your manager makes it clear that their employee isn’t following company policy. In real life, they should ask why this is happening, as having a deeper understanding of the situation will allow them to better assist the other person. 

‍

How learning and development can help support new managers 

Supporting new managers, and providing learning opportunities, is vital to their success. They need the right skills and knowledge to excel, and many begin their roles with more promise than expertise. But the right training can fill gaps in knowledge, help them develop new strengths, and make a difference for your organization. 

‍

Eager to learn more? Reach out to us and we’ll tell you about how we can help you support your people.

‍